In Made You Look, one of Stefan Sagmeister’s life goals is to touch somebody’s heard with graphic design. He attempts to come up with a list of qualities that a given design must have in order to make that happen (no guarantees though):
I must say, it’s a pretty darn good list. There’s so much designs out there, but most of them will only meet only 2 or 3 of the above. It’s really really difficult to achieve all 6 goals with one single design piece.
Stefan also adds one last bit of advice which I agree with readily. He says:
I guess the list has the same problem as all those “How do I make other people love me?” books. If I want to touch somebody’s heart with a piece of design, it has to come from my heart, it has to be true and sincere. Mere list-following won’t do.